Methodological and Statistical Services

Racial and ethnic disparities in birth outcomes: a life-course perspective
Lu, M. C., & Halfon, N. (2003). Racial and ethnic disparities in birth outcomes: a life-course perspective. Maternal & Child Health Journal, 7(1), 13-30.

Health Disparities (HD) are notoriously hard to identify reliably; moreover finding what causes them, and hence how to reduce and eliminate them, is especially difficult, but models exist (see the Framework for Health equity below, the birth outcomes illustration, and other conceptual and practical models).

The main reason is that simple group comparisons of a health outcome is not enough to conclude that HDs exist, and to what extent they do. Such group comparisons need to ‘take into account’ outside causal factors (like neighborhood, or socio-economic conditions) that ‘partially explain’ the raw difference we notice at first. We can provide advice on such matters, e.g.:

  1. How and why and what to ‘control for’ when deciding the extent of HDs is what we can provide assistance with, to researchers but also community stakeholders interested in extracting and translating evidence, so that it can become actionable.
  2. How can one distinguish between: inequities/differences/disparities/discrimination. There are ways to test for discrimination, one involving assessing residual direct effects after explaining other mechanisms that may operate, or specific mediators like implicit prejudice.
  3. How can make causal claims in the HD world:

3.1. Can race/ethnicity ‘cause’ health outcomes? Can gender cause them? It is debatable, but there are ways to handle this better/worse.

3.2. What not to ‘control for’ when comparing groups: an intermediate outcome is problematic for example, others even more problematic.

A Framework for Health Equity
Tony Iton “Framework for Health Equity”, referenced in the text: Tackling Health Inequities Through Public Health Practice: Theory to Action. Edited by Richard Hofrichter and Rajiv Bhatia. Based on a project by the National Association of County and City Health Officials. Oxford University Press, 2010 (page 380). Adapted by ACPHD from the Bay Area Regional Health Inequities Initiative, Summer 2008.

3.3. Various matching methods exist that allow for true comparability; such matching may induce at times relationships between variables that are not manifest in the entire population.

3.4. Instead of having race/ethnicity ‘cause’ health, one can compare populations in simple and complex ways of causal relationships.

  1. How to apply a person/patient-centered view to HDs: what can statistics tell us about Darnell‘s vs. Jake’s vs. Jose’s health outcomes, and how can this provide feedback to their health care providers.

3.4. A practical solution is to find completely identical Darnell and Jake and compare their patient experiences and outcomes.

  1. Measuring race and ethnicity are the pillars of HD answers, yet these are difficult to measure reliably, better solutions exist of course.
  2. We can specifically help with gathering, processing and analyzing health data to develop health disparities dashboards/reports for health care providers of other stakeholders interested in this.

 

We list below some modeling resources (papers, software code for analyses, outputs) that refer to some of our prior work.

Helpful Tips and Supplementary Materials

1  Models and Outputs
Statistical power of alternative structural models for comparative effectiveness research: advantages of modeling unreliability. 

Contact coman@uchc.edu for detailed appendix.

3  Mplus Outputs
"Ethnic differences of the mediating effects of anxiety and actual social support on the relation between stress and depression in community-dwelling older adults." 

Contact coman@uchc.edu for detailed appendix.

5  AMOS Model and Data
"The paired t-test as a simple latent change score model."

Contact coman@uchc.edu for detailed appendix.

6  Poster “Challenges in assessing impact of an intervention to reduce HIV when comparison data is not available”.

7  AMOS Model and Poster “A layman’s visual modeling introduction to latent change score analysis”.

9  Poster Latent Variables 
“On the uses, benefits and interpretive meanings of latent variables in Comparative Effectiveness (CE) research” 12th annual CT - American Statistical Association mini-conference.

10  MPlus CFA outputs 
“Development and validation of the Medical Home Care Coordination Survey for assessing care coordination in the primary care setting from the patient and provider perspectives”, NIHFree PDF.

11  Online appendix (syntaxes and outputs)

The utility of well-designed graphical displays for statistical analyses.

The omnipresence of latent variables in statistics.